Automixing 10 min read
Automixing: One Conversation, Fewer Open Microphones
Compare gating and gain-sharing automixers, manage open microphones and configure speech mixing for standard and divisible rooms.
- Explain why multiple open microphones degrade a system.
- Distinguish gating and gain-sharing automixers.
- Understand NOM attenuation, last-mic hold and priority.
- Use automixer direct outputs and logic without breaking the mix.
- Configure automixing correctly in standard and divisible rooms.
Why an AV engineer should care
Imagine an eight-person conference table with eight microphones. If all eight remain fully open, the far end hears eight copies of the room:
- HVAC noise
- Loudspeaker spill
- Chair movement
- Reflections
- People shuffling papers with extraordinary determination
Multiple microphones may also capture the same talker at slightly different times, producing comb filtering and hollow speech. In locally reinforced systems, every additional open microphone reduces available gain before feedback.
An automixer continuously decides how much each microphone should contribute. It does not replace proper microphone placement, gain structure or AEC. It manages already-processed microphone channels so the useful talkers dominate the mix.
1. The number-of-open-microphones problem
NOM means Number of Open Microphones.
As more microphones open, their uncorrelated noise and acoustic pickup combine. A useful rule is:
NOM penalty=10 log₁₀(N)
| Open microphones | Approximate penalty |
|---|---|
| 1 | 0 dB |
| 2 | 3 dB |
| 4 | 6 dB |
| 8 | 9 dB |
| 16 | 12 dB |
Every doubling of the number of open microphones costs approximately 3 dB of gain before feedback. Shure includes the same NOM term in its potential-acoustic-gain calculation, while Biamp uses the corresponding 10log(NOM) relationship for automixer attenuation. (shure.com, support.biamp.com)
That does not mean four microphones always make a system exactly 6 dB worse. Microphone patterns, positions, room acoustics and loudspeaker coverage still matter. It is a reliable engineering model for understanding the trend.
Automixing helps by:
- Attenuating unused microphones.
- Favoring the microphone closest to the talker.
- Maintaining a more consistent total system gain.
- Reducing noise, reverberation and comb filtering.
- Improving gain before feedback in reinforced systems.
Biamp identifies those same three core benefits: better signal-to-noise ratio, better gain before feedback and reduced comb filtering. (support.biamp.com)
2. Gating automixers
A gating automixer decides whether each microphone is active or inactive.
Conceptually, it asks:
Is this microphone receiving speech that is sufficiently above the current room noise?
If yes, it opens the channel. When speech stops, it waits for a hold period and then attenuates the channel.
A modern automixer may use an adaptive threshold that moves with the room’s ambient-noise level. Biamp calls its version Adaptive Threshold Sensing, or ATS. The algorithm continuously compares the microphone signals and adjusts the opening threshold as the ambient level changes. (support.biamp.com, tesira-help.biamp.com)
Typical gating controls include:
- Sensitivity or threshold: How easily a channel opens.
- Attack: How quickly it opens.
- Hold: How long it stays open after speech stops.
- Release: How quickly it returns to its attenuated state.
- Off attenuation: How far an inactive channel is reduced.
- Maximum NOM: Maximum channels permitted to open together.
“Inactive” does not necessarily mean completely muted. An off attenuation of –15 dB allows some room sound through. An attenuation of –80 dB is effectively a mute.
Gating advantages
- Strong isolation between microphones
- Predictable maximum-open-microphone behavior
- Useful in noisy or reflective rooms
- Helpful for speech reinforcement and camera logic
- Easier to see which microphone is considered active
Gating problems
Poor settings can produce:
- Missing first syllables
- Words chopped off during pauses
- Gates opened by HVAC or paper noise
- Audible room ambience switching on and off
- Rapid camera switching between nearby microphones
The cure is rarely “make everything more aggressive.” Start with proper microphone gain and placement, then adjust threshold and timing.
3. Gain-sharing automixers
A gain-sharing automixer does not classify every channel as simply open or closed. It continuously distributes a shared gain budget according to the relative activity on the inputs.
If one person speaks, that microphone receives most of the available gain.
If two equally strong talkers speak, the automixer shares the gain between them. Each might receive approximately 3 dB less than a single talker, maintaining roughly the same total system gain.
Shure describes its gain-sharing mode as distributing system gain across the channels so their combined contribution equals approximately one open microphone. (shure.com, pubs.shure.com)
Gain-sharing advantages
- Smooth and natural conversational transitions
- Less obvious opening and closing
- Good behavior during overlapping speech
- Consistent total system gain
- Useful in acoustically controlled conference rooms
Gain-sharing limitations
- Ambient noise may remain more noticeable
- Poorly matched channel gains distort the decisions
- Loud background noises may “steal” gain
- One group should not span independent acoustic rooms
- Gate-state logic for camera tracking may be less definite
The platform may still display a dominant channel or applied-gain value, but those values are continuously moving.
| Situation | Common starting choice |
|---|---|
| Quiet boardroom | Gain sharing |
| Noisy council chamber | Gating |
| Speech reinforcement | Gating |
| Natural roundtable conversation | Gain sharing |
| Camera tracking requiring definite states | Gating, or carefully filtered gain-share data |
These are starting points. Current Q-SYS guidance, for example, recommends gating in more reflective rooms and gain sharing for smaller microphone counts in acoustically favorable rooms. (support.qsys.com)
4. NOM attenuation
A gating automixer may allow several microphones to open at once. NOM attenuation reduces the mix as more microphones open:
- One microphone: 0 dB
- Two microphones: approximately –3 dB
- Four microphones: approximately –6 dB
- Eight microphones: approximately –9 dB
This prevents the output level, room noise and feedback risk from rising sharply every time another person speaks.
Gain-sharing automixers accomplish a similar goal intrinsically by redistributing a fixed amount of gain.
NOM settings vary by manufacturer. Some apply attenuation to the main mix only. Others can apply it to direct outputs. Some allow a custom attenuation step rather than the traditional 3 dB-per-doubling relationship. Treat the manufacturer’s NOM controls as implementation-specific.
5. Last-mic hold
If every microphone closes during a pause, the far end suddenly hears silence. When someone speaks again, the room ambience returns. That change can sound like a broken connection or a noise gate breathing.
Last-mic hold keeps the most recently active microphone partially or fully open until another microphone takes over.
Shure describes its purpose as maintaining natural room sound so remote participants know the audio path has not been interrupted. (shure.com)
Use it cautiously in noisy rooms. If the last microphone happens to be beside a roaring air handler, last-mic hold may faithfully preserve the worst seat in the building.
Some automixers let you designate a preferred default microphone, such as a central ceiling lobe, instead of holding whichever one happened to open last.
6. Priority and maximum-open limits
A priority channel receives preference over ordinary microphones.
Useful applications include:
- Chairperson microphone
- Lectern microphone
- Instructor position
- Emergency announcement input
- Judge or council president position
Priority may simply make a channel easier to open, or it may attenuate other microphones. Behavior varies by product.
Use strong priority sparingly. If the chairperson shuffles papers, breathes heavily or whispers to a neighbor, the automixer should not make everyone else disappear.
A maximum-open-microphone limit prevents too many channels from opening simultaneously. This can help stabilize reinforced systems, but a limit of one is usually wrong for conferencing because it makes simultaneous conversation sound half-duplex.
7. Direct outputs, logic and camera tracking
Many automixers provide:
- A combined automix output
- Individual direct outputs
- Open/closed logic states
- Applied-gain meters
Direct outputs are useful for:
- Multitrack recording
- Camera tracking
- Separate reinforcement zones
- Custom mix-minus routing
- Per-microphone level monitoring
Check where the direct output is tapped. It might be:
- Before automixing
- After the channel gate
- After NOM attenuation
- After post-gate gain
Q-SYS, for example, provides options for applying NOM attenuation to direct outputs when those outputs will be mixed elsewhere. (help.qsys.com)
For camera tracking, do not switch cameras on every instantaneous gate change. Add:
- Minimum open time
- Dominant-talker delay
- Camera hold time
- Protection against rapid switching
- A defined wide-shot fallback
Someone coughing should not receive an immediate dramatic close-up.
8. Practical example: MXA920 and room DSP
An MXA920 can perform automixing internally and provide an automix output. Shure currently offers gating, gain-sharing and manual modes in its IntelliMix processing. (shure.com)
A clean architecture is:
MXA coverage areas → AEC and IntelliMix processing → MXA automix output → Q-SYS/Biamp routing → USB transmit
If the MXA owns automixing, do not place its combined output into a second automixer. The DSP sees that signal as one processed microphone mix.
Alternatively, send individual microphone channels to the room DSP and let the DSP perform AEC and automixing. In that architecture:
Individual mic channels → DSP AEC → mic processing → DSP automixer
Choose one owner for AEC and one owner for automixing. Record both choices on the functional drawing.
9. Practical example: divisible airwall rooms
Consider the earlier system:
- Two microphones in Room A
- Two microphones in Room B
- Two microphones at the airwall
Separate mode
- Room A microphones use Room A’s automixer.
- Room B microphones use Room B’s automixer.
- Airwall microphones remain disabled.
- The two automixers operate as independent gain groups.
Do not place both rooms in one gain-sharing group while separated. A loud talker in Room A could take gain away from a quiet talker in Room B even though they are conducting unrelated meetings.
Combined mode
- All six microphones join one coordinated automix group.
- Airwall microphones become active.
- NOM and last-mic behavior apply across the combined room.
- The combined automix feeds the appropriate conference and recording buses.
Biamp’s Auto Mixer Combiner is an example of a vendor-specific component that shares NOM, adaptive-threshold and last-mic information across multiple automixer blocks for room combining. (tesira-help.biamp.com)
During mode changes, briefly mute the affected microphone bus while the groups, routes and logic switch. That prevents partly combined automix behavior.
Practical commissioning exercise
Using four microphone channels:
- Match their input gains using one talker at the intended distance.
- Confirm AEC operation before enabling automixing.
- Enable automix-gain or gate-status meters.
- Speak at each position and note which channel dominates.
- Speak between two microphones and observe the decision.
- Have two people talk simultaneously.
- Create paper noise beside an unused microphone.
- Pause for five seconds and observe last-mic hold.
- Compare gating with gain sharing.
- Confirm that no post-automix gain adjustment defeats the NOM behavior.
If the first syllable disappears, reduce the opening threshold or increase sensitivity. If microphones remain open for chair noise, improve placement or make the detection less sensitive. If room noise audibly appears and disappears, adjust hold, release, off attenuation or last-mic behavior.
Compact glossary
- Automixer: Processor that automatically controls multiple microphone contributions.
- NOM: Number of open microphones.
- NOM attenuation: Gain reduction applied as more microphones become active.
- Gate: Processor that attenuates a channel below a detection threshold.
- Gain sharing: Continuous distribution of gain based on channel activity.
- Off attenuation: Reduction applied to an inactive channel.
- Hold time: Delay before an inactive microphone begins closing.
- Last-mic hold: Keeps one microphone active during conversational pauses.
- Priority: Preference given to a selected microphone.
- Direct output: Individual channel output taken from an automixer.
- ATS: Adaptive Threshold Sensing; Biamp’s term for adaptive gating logic.
Review questions
- Why does opening more microphones reduce available gain before feedback?
- What is the basic difference between gating and gain sharing?
- Why should separated rooms not remain in one gain-sharing group?
Answers
-
Each open microphone adds another acoustic feedback path and additional noise. Every doubling of open microphones produces approximately a 3 dB penalty.
-
Gating classifies channels as active or attenuated. Gain sharing continuously distributes a common gain budget according to relative channel activity.
-
Activity in one room could reduce microphone gain in the other, causing two unrelated meetings to affect each other.
Discuss a project